Yesterday…   As In The Movie And Ralph’s Life



First of all, go see Danny Boyle’s movie YESTERDAY. I laughed and cried and had the best time I’ve had at a movie since, gosh, I was thirteen when my friend Dorothy and I got my mother to drive us four hours from Pennsylvania into NY City to see Albert Finney as TOM JONES ( the same weekend the Beetles were in NY City to begin a tour; after the movie, my mother took us for Chinese food at a restaurant where Dorothy and I may or may not have walked past George Harrison, but that’s another story).

I went to YESTERDAY with a friend who’d already been once but wanted to go again. When I came home I called and wrote everyone I could  to recommend the movie. Then I sat down to write about it here because, after all, the premise is all about memory.

In the movie, the Beatles and their music (like other random items we all take for granted) has never existed for most of the world’s population. Or put another way, most of the world’s population has forgotten the Beatles ever existed. So the link between memory and personal reality couldn’t be stronger:

In the film, all the people who don’t have the Beatles in their mental database don’t miss them. And yet. And yet, the loss of what they don’t know is palpable to those who do remember (including the audience). So when the songs are reintroduced to the unremembering world, even in a slightly adulterated, second hand form, the joy is glorious. Not unlike when I show Ralph pictures and videos of joyful moments he doesn’t remember otherwise. The difference is that in the movie, people get to keep hearing those songs in their heads once they’re reintroduced. For someone with Alzheimer’s, the memory doesn’t stick, has to be reintroduced every time.

But aside from all my possibly pretentious psycho-philosophizing, the movie is just plain fun. I wouldn’t mind seeing it again. My idea was to take Ralph to see it and then finish writing this post by discussing his reaction. Whether or not he followed the plot, I assumed he’d love the music, of which there is a gracious amount, and I hoped hearing the songs would possibly trigger memories for him of what he was doing when he heard Help or Let It Be.

So I scheduled “See movie Yesterday With Alice” into his daily list for Thursday afternoon at 3pm. By mid morning Thursday, Ralph was complaining of a stomachache.

It must have been something I ate…I don’t think I can go to a movie today…Can we re-schedule the movie for another day.”

I wasn’t surprised when he was miraculously better and sitting on the porch with his cigarettes and beer by four that afternoon.

Let’s go Saturday then,” I said.

What’s the movie about again?”

“The Beatles, and what if no one remembered they existed but one person.”

Definitely,” he said.  “It sounds great.”

Well, here it is Saturday. As he does every morning, Ralph asked me over our first cups of coffee whether anything special was planned today.

The movie about the Beatles,” I said.

Oh, do I have to?” he said. “It’s just I don’t like sitting in a chair at the theater for so long.”

I looked at this man, who sits four or five hours at a time in his porch chair and realized I was hanging on to an idea of Ralph as moviegoer that I had to give up. It was not boredom or muscle pain he feared but being trapped in a world he couldn’t follow. He no longer has the capacity for concentration and comprehension that we both used to take as for granted as we did the Beatles.

“No, of course you don’t have to go.” Not today or tomorrow. Movies have become part of Ralph’s yesterday.

10 thoughts on “Yesterday…   As In The Movie And Ralph’s Life

  1. I wonder what I would do in his situation. I like to think I would acknowledge my condition and seek my spouse’s support and understanding. My wife already criticizes me for being forgetful. I pointed out to her, that if I am I can’t help it. I asked her how supportive she was going to be if and when I develop dementia. I think too it would be time for me, in his situation, to consider suicide. I am thankful to God for my excellent mental and physical health.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thanks for writing and wish you continued health. I don’t think suicide is the answer. Ralph can be anxious, but he is seldom unhappy. In fact living in the moment as he does, he is often much happier than those of us who worry about past mistakes and future dangers all the time


  2. This happened for us as well. J became less interested in tv and movies, would defer to me any time I asked what she might like to watch. Took me a long time to realize she wasn’t just deferring to be polite, but more about saving face – like Mary said. It’s hard to conceal memory loss when people are chatting about a plot, or a tv series.
    I appreciate your loss. Take care.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. SAVING FACE! Exactly. At this stage so much is about recognizing what is possible, what is not and how much saving face figures into the equation. Thanks so much for articulating what is so key….

      Liked by 1 person

  3. My sister saw Yesterday and loved it. I’m hoping to have the chance to catch it soon. Glad you enjoyed it. Sorry Ralph won’t be joining you to watch films. It’s probably not the sitting for so long that’s the problem but the concentration required to follow a storyline.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. You are so right. I just clarified in the post. It is not boredom or discomfort he was worried about but being trapped in the film world he couldn’t understand. I can see his unspoken confusion when he tries to watch any narrative. Thanks for making sure I articulate the reality to myself. Easy to fudge….You will definitely love the movie.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s